1.866.412.4880

Second Source Qualification for Sealing Components

Need to Qualify an Alternate Seal Source?

When an existing seal supplier cannot meet lead-time, capacity, or supply continuity requirements, ESP helps OEMs identify, evaluate, and qualify alternative sources. Leveraging application engineering, supplier-quality, global sourcing, and PPAP support capabilities, ESP evaluates alternate materials, compounds, manufacturers, and inventory strategies to help maintain performance, compliance, and production continuity. With more than 50 years of sealing experience and relationships with leading global manufacturers, ESP provides customers with practical pathways to qualified second source solutions.

When Does a Second Source Make Sense?

A second source qualification may be appropriate when:

  • Lead times are affecting production
  • The current supplier cannot support required volume
  • A seal or compound has been discontinued
  • Cost or availability has changed significantly
  • A supplier or manufacturing location has changed
  • A legacy drawing references an unavailable or proprietary part
  • Supply continuity has become a concern

The objective is not just to identify another supplier. Each alternate source is evaluated against the critical requirements that define application performance and regulatory compliance.

What ESP Reviews

Successful second source qualification requires more than matching a part number. ESP evaluates technical, commercial, and compliance requirements to determine whether an alternative source can support performance, quality, supply continuity, and long-term program objectives.

Technical Review

  • Geometry and dimensional requirements
  • Material and performance requirements
  • Operating conditions and application environment
  • Manufacturing processes and quality controls
  • Validation and qualification requirements

Commercial Review

  • Supply continuity and sourcing risk
  • Lead times and inventory strategy
  • Total cost of ownership
  • Implementation impact
  • Long-term supply considerations

Compliance, Documentation & Traceability

Qualification requirements often extend beyond dimensions and material specifications. ESP evaluates applicable regulatory, industry, customer, and quality-system requirements to help ensure an alternate source can be approved, documented, and supported throughout the product lifecycle.

Typical considerations include:

  • Material certifications and traceability requirements
  • PPAP and customer-specific approval requirements
  • Certificates of Conformance and supporting documentation
  • FDA, NSF, UL, aerospace, military, or other regulatory requirements
  • Change management and record retention requirements

Documentation, compliance, and manufacturing-source requirements are integrated into the qualification process to support traceability, audit readiness, and long-term supply continuity.

View our QMS Process

View our ISO & AS9120 Certifications

Equivalent Does Not Mean Identical

A second source qualification does not always require a material change. In some cases, an alternate manufacturer can produce the same design using the same specified compound and quality requirements. In other situations, an equivalent material, alternate manufacturing process, or modified design may be evaluated to improve availability, performance, cost, or supply continuity. The appropriate approach depends on the technical, commercial, and compliance requirements of the application.A qualified alternate does not always need to come from the same manufacturer or use the same proprietary compound designation. What matters is whether the replacement meets the requirements of the application and the customer’s qualification process.

ESP works with multiple sealing manufacturers and material sources, allowing our team to evaluate:

  • Alternate Qualified Materials
  • Multiple Manufacturing Sources

Define the Existing Part
Provide the available information, including a drawing, part number, current supplier, material specification, compound designation, sample, or application details.

Identify Critical Requirements
ESP collaborates with your engineering and sourcing teams to define the dimensional, material, performance, quality, documentation, and compliance requirements that must be maintained throughout the process.

Evaluate Alternate Options
Potential materials, compounds, manufacturing methods, and sources are compared against the application requirements.

Review the Manufacturing Process
When required, ESP supports tooling and fixture review, manufacturing process verification, dimensional inspection, capability analysis, and supplier quality requirements to ensure readiness before production approval.

Prototype, Sample, & Validate
Samples or prototypes can be supplied for dimensional, functional, or application testing when qualification requires validation before release.

Transition to Production Supply
Once approved, ESP supports production requirements, inventory planning, stocking programs, and ongoing supply to maintain consistent operations.

Reducing Supply Risk Without Creating Engineering Risk

The fastest or lowest-cost alternate does not always deliver the required performance or reliability. Changing material, compound, manufacturing process, or supplier can introduce unintended performance or compliance risks if application requirements are not fully defined and managed.

ESP helps balance four priorities (APQC):

  1. Availability
    1. Can the part be supplied reliably at the required volume and lead time?
  2. Performance
    1. Will the alternate perform in the actual operating environment?
  3. Qualification
    1. Can the new source meet the required testing, documentation, and approval process?
  4. Cost
    1. Does the alternate provide sustainable value without introducing unnecessary risk?

The objective is a qualified second source that strengthens supply continuity while maintaining sealing system performance and compliance.

Why OEMs Choose ESP

  • 50+ years supporting OEM sealing applications
  • Parker Seal Technology Center
  • Freudenberg Preferred Partner
  • PPAP and qualification support capabilities
  • Application engineering resources
  • Supply continuity and inventory programs
  • Support for OEM and aftermarket requirements

Need to Qualify a Second Source?

Send ESP the current part number, drawing, material specification, sample, or application requirements. Our engineering, sourcing, and supplier-quality teams can help evaluate alternate materials, compounds, manufacturers, documentation, and production options.